Weeping, Wailing and Gnashing of Teeth

It all began in grade school when some well-meaning librarian figured me out as a sensitive kid who liked to read and handed me a copy of Bridge to Terabithia. Henceforth, that librarian will be known as the stone cold witch who killed my innocence and made me cry. At the time, I was cool with the fact that many beloved characters–Sara Crewe (A Little Princess), Little Orphan Annie, Mary Lennox (The Secret Garden)–had dead parents. First of all, we never really met the parents so their loss had little impact. Secondly, these orphans were always adopted by fantastically rich people and ended up fabulously happy. Bridge to Terabithia? Not so happy an ending.

I don’t think I need a spoiler alert, but in case you still have Bridge to Terabithia on your Goodreads “want to read” shelf, then stop here and go get it already. It was published in 1977 so you’ve had ample time. I am one of those people who do not remember much from childhood, but I specifically remember reading this book, sobbing uncontrollably, and wondering why, oh why, this stone cold witch who killed my innocence and made me cry thought I should be exposed to such tragedy. Didn’t she know I would be destroyed when Leslie, the young female protagonist, died in a senseless accident? Now, as a librarian myself, I understand that she read the book, recognized its greatness, and wanted to share it with someone. When I think about it that way, it is actually kind of flattering that she wanted to share it with me…or would be if she hadn’t shattered my innocence and crushed my heart. You know a book is powerful if you still remember the story–and your visceral reaction to it–thirty-five years later.

I’m still blubbering over great books, probably more than usual lately. Typically, it isn’t over a character’s death. In fact, I recently read a book where the main character’s best friend committed suicide, but I wasn’t emotionally invested enough to have much of a reaction. Yet, in the following books, I went totally Terabithia. Great writing does that to me.


Blackbird Fly by Erin Entrada Kelly – I randomly checked this book out of the public library because l loved the cover and the jacket copy. It turned out to be one of the best coming-of-age books I have ever read. Apple Yengko is a badass. She is the only Filipino girl at her school, longs to play guitar like George Harrison, and has just found out she is on the Dog Log at her school. As someone who was called a “dog” in junior high by a boy I liked (Or maybe by his best friend? I can’t remember. I told you my memory is bad.) I related to Apple’s situation. Boys can be cruel. Girls can be worse. Those who survive middle school are warriors, and Apple…she really rises above. After reading this book I almost wanted to go back to junior high and have a do-over. Almost.

Eleanor and Park by Rainbow Rowell – Friends have been raving about this book for years. I finally got it and when I started out, I didn’t think it was going to live up to the hype. By the end, I was a weepy mess. It’s the underdog love story of the century. Seriously, what book have you ever read where the chubby, unkempt girl gets to be the romantic lead without first getting a makeover? And the male romantic lead is an introspective Asian American boy? Never. Happens. Rowell makes you fall in love with Eleanor and Park, and I’m still making up stories in my head about what happens to the two of them after the book ends. (P.S. Loved this fan art.)

I highly recommend both of the books above if you need a great read and a good cry. See also: Wonder by R.J. Palacio, Walk Two Moons by Sharon Creech and Sorta Like a Rock Star by Matthew Quick. Or you can go old school and check out Bridge to Terabithia, but don’t say I didn’t warn you…


Go Ahead…Make My Day

I love the challenge of being asked for book recommendations. You may think kids are open to book suggestions from librarians because (a) they are the ones asking me for book suggestions (b) I am a grown-up who spent two years getting my graduate degree in library science (c) these are the people who often refer to me as “the book lady.” If you think any of these things matter to a kid, you are wrong. Most of these little people are a hard sell. Sometimes they seem to want to reject everything I throw out there, but that doesn’t stop me. I am a book machine. And if their parents are the ones asking for suggestions, the challenge just intensifies. Bring it!

I always ask which books the child has enjoyed previously so I can get a feel for their taste. It’s also helpful to know what they didn’t like so I don’t suggest something they previously rejected. Nothing kills my credibility like offering a book that they think is a loser.

Today, a mom at school asked me for some summer reading suggestions for her son who is a rising third grader. This kid is way cooler than I am so I knew I had my work cut out for me. Here are the stats:

Book series he loved:

  • Shredderman
  • Geronimo Stilton
  • Magic Treehouse

Book series he rejected:

  • Diary of a Wimpy Kid (said it was “too easy,” which I didn’t really understand, but I went with it because it made sense to him)
  • 29 Clues (he just made a face at the mention of this one — see, I dodged that bullet because I mentioned it, but did not recommend it. I’m a librarian ninja!)

Parent request: something more challenging than early faves like Magic Treehouse

Child request: some humor, possibly illustration

I like to think of myself as crunching data like Google, but let’s be honest, my brain is much more random. Here is what I came up with for him:

1. Origami Yoda series by Tom Angleberger — I think he should try this series first. The humor will appeal to him, and it feels like a good fit for his personality. yoda

2. The My Life series by Janet Tashjian — This series has the illustration component to it, some humor and a relatable main character. Strong contender.

3. Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing by Judy Blume — This is a classic good stuff. It doesn’t have much illustration, but I think the characters and humor will appeal to him.

4. Hank Zipzer series by Henry Winkler and Lin Oliver — Disclosure: I have not read this series. I still think it might appeal to him from the description. Maybe it’s a back-up possibility.

5. The Lemonade War — I’m not sure if his teacher read this to the class already. If not, I think the conflict would appeal to him.

What would you recommend for this little dude?